Trump's first two weeks on the environment: The Bad, the Good and the Ugly

both

The White House

It’s been two chaotic, unsettling weeks since Donald Trump was inaugurated. Whoever first offered the curse, “May you live in interesting times,” knew what he was talking about.

For those who want progress toward a cleaner environment, it’s been a challenging 14 days. Here are a few thoughts about developments we’ve seen so far.

THE BAD

President Trump’s campaign was filled with anti-environmental rhetoric and since the election he’s been making clear that he meant it.

Big oil lobby scored

The president began by nominating a cabinet that’s radically imbalanced toward big energy interests: the chief executive of ExxonMobil for Secretary of State, oil-industry ally Rick Perry for the top job at the energy department, and Scott Pruitt to run the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency – the agency he’s sued 14 times to block clean air and water rules.

Like much about this president, there was nothing subtle about these picks. Big oil and gas lobbyists got what they wanted.

Rules being killed, arbitrarily

Next, the president issued a series of troubling executive orders, including one that requires two rules or safeguards to be withdrawn for every new one that’s issued. It’s a blunt instrument that ignores whether the rules are effective, necessary for public health, or needed to make our economy function properly.

This arbitrary ratio is far more of a political statement than a real effort to make government work more efficiently. Its impacts could be serious.

Congress plays along

The administration’s allies in Congress are on the same course.

The House has already passed bills to require that almost all significant federal regulations be approved by both houses of Congress before taking effect. It may sound reasonable until you consider that critical government rules on clean air, children’s health and any other subject can be held up by a handful of senators.

Equally alarming: Such radical new policies replace expert analysis based on science and law with a highly political, unscientific process.

Yet another bill would sunset all existing regulations after 10 years, reopening long settled issues like child labor, food safety and financial security.

Maybe most self-defeating, the House endorsed a bill that allows leaks from natural gas wells to continue on federal and tribal laws. The gas belongs to the public so cancelling this rule will cost taxpayers up to $800 million in lost royalties over the next decade, while increasing air and climate pollution.

In their zeal to strip away anything labeled “regulation,” lawmakers are busy rolling back common sense.

THE GOOD

Yes, there has been some good in the Trump era.

We the People are standing up

Mostly importantly, there’s been an enormous surge in citizen activism. The streets have been filled with protesters, demanding a return to government that serves the public first. At the women’s marches the day after Trump’s inauguration, many people also carried signs calling for environmental protection.

The surge in citizenship hasn’t just been in the streets. Sen. Brian Schatz reports that the United States Capitol switchboard is busier than at any point in history, with almost double the call volume.

Activism is already paying off

As Americans join together, advocacy groups are gaining new supporters. In fact, Environmental Defense Fund just passed two million members and activists, with historic growth since the November elections. Americans are taking back their democracy.

Best of all, there are indications the activism is having an impact. After an outcry, the Trump administration paused plans to wipe away climate information on the EPA web site – though stay tuned. Public pressure also forced EPA pick Scott Pruitt to claim a change in position on mercury pollution during his hearings.

And on the natural gas leak vote earlier today, 11 Republican members of the House broke with leadership.

THE UGLY

But there are many ugly fights ahead.

Environmental rules on the chopping block

If and when Trump is able to push his cabinet through, these agency leaders will begin implementing his policies in earnest.

The Clean Power Plan, which reduces pollution and established American leadership on clean energy and climate, has been targeted for attack. The Paris international climate agreement, the first in history to join developed and developing nations in the effort to limit climate pollution, will be the subject of battles inside and outside the administration.

How it plays out will depend on who tires of the battle first.

In a larger sense, the momentum toward clean energy and strong health protections is at risk. With an administration run entirely by industry allies and those ideologically opposed to the idea of government action, there will many battles to come.

So, 14 days in, we’ve seen an administration set on a dangerous course, and millions of citizens determined to turn them back. How it plays out will depend on who tires of the battle first.

Keith Gaby

Keith Gaby

Explores the intersection of politics and climate change.

Get new posts by email

We'll deliver a daily digest to your inbox.


RSS RSS feed

Comments

no, the ugly, ugly, ugly.

To the fools who thought [Trump] would help you: Time to join the resist movement and to get Congress to impeach him.

I agree 100% we need to get him out!

I am scared that I am going to die leaving such a sorry state of affairs to my grandchildren and great grandkids....and scared more for the ones who haven't been born yet. I have been an activist all my life and now see us sliding backward. Rachel Carson is turning over in her grave. Clean air and water is life. It looks so bleak ahead of us now. I wouldn't recommend anyone having children, only to have them be poisoned, killed or die from a toxic Earth. I am a pale face, but [believe] the Indians are right.

We must stand up for the Constitutional Law of America.

Perhaps the biggest danger to this country, and something I've been noticing and commenting on for years, is apathy: voter apathy, consumer apathy, market place apathy. And apathetic attitudes toward things like racism, poverty, the power of the Federal Reserve, Wall Street, big banks and their power to manipulate markets, the excursion of American jobs out of the nation, and the huge influx of dangerous and undocumented immigrants!

We the People have stood aside for so long and simply allowed things to happen with no regard to righteousness, integrity or fiscal responsibility. But now a great awakening is taking place. New-found and young voters are educating themselves and becoming active, vocal, and popular! Lets keep this mess rolling. It'll clean itself up and gain momentum and purpose as it does!

Has it really been only two weeks? So much destruction in such a short time. Terrifying.