D.C. Circuit cases on state authority

D.C. Circuit Court Cases

Filings on Feb. 1, 2021 Abeyance Motion

• Order Granting Abeyance
  Feb. 8, 2021
• EPA and NHTSA’s Reply in Support of Abeyance
  Feb. 5, 2021
• Ohio et al.'s Opposition to Abeyance
  Feb. 3, 2021
• EPA and NHTSA’s Motion to Hold Case in Abeyance
  Feb. 1, 2021

Merits Briefs

• Joint Appendix
  Oct. 20, 2020
• NGOs’ and States’ Reply Brief
  Oct. 13, 2020
• Industry Petitioners’ Reply Brief
  Oct. 13, 2020
• Automakers’ and AFPM’s Respondent-Intervenor Brief
  Sept. 22, 2020
• Ohio et al.’s Respondent-Intervenor Brief
  Sept. 21, 2020
• Amicus Brief of U.S. Chamber of Commerce in Support of Respondents
  Sept. 16, 2020
• Amicus Brief of Urban Air Initiative in Support of Respondents
  Sept. 16, 2020
• EPA and NHTSA’s Brief
  Sept. 9, 2020
• Amicus Brief of California Climate Scientists
  July 6, 2020
• Amicus Brief of Lyft
  July 6, 2020
• Amicus Brief of Former Secretaries of DOT and Former Administrators of EPA
  July 6, 2020
• Amicus Brief of Institute for Policy Integrity
  July 6, 2020
• Amicus Brief of National Association of Clean Air Agencies
  July 6, 2020
• Amicus Brief of Thomas Jorling, Michael Walsh, Margo Oge
  July 6, 2020
• Amicus Brief of Members of Congress
  July 6, 2020
• Corrected Amicus Brief of National League of Cities et al.
  July 28, 2020
• Amicus Brief of Professor Leah Litman
  July 6, 2020
• Amicus Brief of Edison Electric Institute
  July 6, 2020
• Amicus Brief of Health and Medical Organizations
  July 2, 2020
• Amicus Brief of National Parks Organizations
  July 1, 2020
• NGOs' and States' Brief
  June 29, 2020
• NGOs’ and States’ Statutory Addendum and Standing Declarations
  Nov. 24, 2020
• Industry Petitioners' Brief
  June 26, 2020

Administrative Record Filings

• Order on Briefing Format and Administrative Record Motions
  May 20, 2020
• Petitioners’ Reply in Support of Motion to Complete Administrative Record
  March 16, 2020
• EPA and NHTSA’s Response to Motion to Complete Administrative Record
  March 9, 2020
• Petitioners’ Joint Motion to Complete Administrative Record
  Feb. 27, 2020
• EPA and NHTSA’s Corrected Certified Indexes to Administrative Record
  Feb. 26, 2020
• EPA and NHTSA’s Certified Indexes to Administrative Record
  Jan. 9, 2020

Filings on Abeyance and Expedition Motions

• Order Denying Motions to Expedite and to Hold in Abeyance
  Feb. 4, 2020
• NGOs’ Reply in Support of Abeyance
  Jan. 17, 2020
• States’ Reply in Support of Abeyance
  Jan. 17, 2020
• Automakers’ Reply in Support of Expedition
  Jan. 17, 2020
• EPA and NHTSA’s Reply in Support of Expedition
  Jan. 17, 2020
• NGOs’ Opposition to Expedition
  Jan. 10, 2020
• States’ Opposition to Expedition
  Jan. 10, 2020
• Industry Petitioners’ Opposition to Expedition
  Jan. 10, 2020
• Automakers’ Opposition to Abeyance
  Jan. 10, 2020
• EPA and NHTSA’s Opposition to Abeyance
  Jan. 10, 2020
• Industry Petitioners’ Joinder in Abeyance Motions
  Jan. 3, 2020
• NGOs’ Motion to Hold Case in Abeyance
  Dec. 26, 2019
• States’ Motion to Hold Case in Abeyance
  Dec. 26, 2019
• Automakers’ Motion to Expedite
  Dec. 24, 2019
• EPA and NHTSA’s Motion to Expedite
  Dec. 18, 2019

Filings on Case Management

• Order Consolidating Cases
  June 3, 2020
• NGO and Industry Petitioners’ Motion to Consolidate Cases
  June 2, 2020
• NGOs’ Protective Petition for Review
  May 28, 2020
• Industry Petitioners’ Protective Petition for Review
  May 28, 2020
• Parties’ Notice of Consent to Amicus Filings
  May 26, 2020
• Order on Briefing Format and Administrative Record Motions
  May 20, 2020
• Automakers’ Opposition to Petitioners’ Second Supplemental Response on Briefing Format
  May 11, 2020
• Ohio et al.’s Opposition to Petitioners’ Second Supplemental Response on Briefing Format
  May 11, 2020
• EPA and NHTSA’s Opposition to Petitioners’ Second Supplemental Response on Briefing Format
  May 11, 2020
• Petitioners’ Second Supplemental Response on Briefing Format
  May 4, 2020
• Petitioners’ Supplemental Response on Briefing Format
  Apr. 3, 2020
• Joint Briefing Proposal
  March 6, 2020

Filings on Parties and Intervention

• Order Granting Automakers’ Motion to Withdraw
  Feb. 22, 2021
• Automakers’ Motion to Withdraw
  Feb. 2, 2021
• Automakers’ Updated Disclosure Statement
  Dec. 4, 2020
• Automakers’ Updated Disclosure Statement
  Nov. 25, 2020
• Order Granting Alaska’s Motion to Withdraw
  Sept. 24, 2020
• Alaska’s Motion to Withdraw
  Sept. 22, 2020
• Order Granting Ohio et al.’s and AFPM’s Intervention
  Jan. 28, 2020
• Automakers’ Updated Disclosure Statement
  Jan. 10, 2020
• AFPM’s Motion to Intervene
  Dec. 13, 2019
• Ohio et al.’s Motion to Intervene as Respondents
  Nov. 26, 2019
• Order Granting Automakers’ Intervention
  Nov. 21, 2019
• CSAR’s Reply in Support of Intervention
  Nov. 19, 2019
• NGOs’ Opposition to CSAR’s Intervention
  Nov. 12, 2019
• Automakers’ Motion to Intervene
  Oct. 31, 2019

Statements of Issues

• Power Companies’ Statement of Issues
  Jan. 2, 2020
• NGOs’ Statement of Issues for EPA Action
  Dec. 26, 2019
• NGOs’ Statement of Issues for NHTSA Action
  Dec. 26, 2019
• States’ Statement of Issues
  Dec. 26, 2019
• Air Districts’ Statement of Issues
  Dec. 26, 2019
• Advanced Energy Economy’s Statement of Issues
  Dec. 26, 2019
• NCAT’s Statement of Issues
  Dec. 23, 2019

Petitions for Review

• Power Companies’ Petition for Review
  Nov. 25, 2019
• Advanced Energy Economy’s Petition for Review
  Nov. 25, 2019
• San Francisco’s Petition for Review
  Nov. 25, 2019
• NGOs’ Petition for Review of EPA Action
  Nov. 22, 2019
• States’ Petition for Review
  Nov. 15, 2019
• NCAT’s Petition for Review
  Nov. 15, 2019
• Air Districts’ Petition for Review
  Nov. 15, 2019
• NGOs’ Protective Petition for Review of NHTSA Action
  Oct. 28, 2019

D.C. District Court Cases

EDF v. Chao, No. 19-2907; California v. Chao, No. 19-2826;
SCAQMD v. Chao, No. 19-3436

Filings on Motion to Dismiss or Transfer

• Order Staying Case
  Feb. 11, 2020
• Defendants’ Response to Notice of Developments in Related Litigation
  Feb. 7, 2020
• States’ and NGOs’ Notice to Court of Developments in Related Litigation
  Feb. 6, 2020
• Order for Hearing on Motion to Dismiss
  Jan. 15, 2020
• Automakers’ Joinder in Motion to Dismiss
  Dec. 6, 2019
• Defendants’ Reply in Support of Motion to Dismiss
  Nov. 27, 2019
• NGO Plaintiffs’ Opposition to Motion to Dismiss
  Nov. 14, 2019
• State Plaintiffs’ Opposition to Motion to Dismiss
  Nov. 14, 2019
• Defendants’ Motion to Dismiss
  Oct. 15, 2019

Filings on Parties and Intervention

• Order Granting Automakers’ Motion to Withdraw
  Feb. 12, 2021
• Automakers’ Motion to Withdraw
  Feb. 2, 2021
• Automakers’ Updated Disclosure Statement
  Jan. 10, 2020
• Order Granting Power Companies’ and NCAT’s Intervention
  Dec. 19, 2019
• Order Granting Automakers’ Intervention
  Dec. 6, 2019
• Power Companies’ Motion to Intervene as Plaintiffs
  Dec. 4, 2019
• Power Companies’ Proposed Complaint
  Dec. 4, 2019
• Automakers’ Motion to Intervene in SCAQMD v. Chao
  Nov. 29, 2019
• NCAT’s Motion to Intervene and Proposed Complaint
  Nov. 15, 2019
• Automakers’ Motion to Intervene
  Oct. 31, 2019

Complaints

• Air Districts’ Complaint
  Nov. 14, 2019
• State Plaintiffs’ First Amended Complaint
  Oct. 8, 2019
• NGO Plaintiffs’ Complaint
  Sept. 27, 2019
• State Plaintiffs’ Complaint
  Sept. 20, 2019

Denver County Colorado District Court

Freedom to Drive v. Colorado Air Quality Control Commission, No. 2019CV34156

Filings on Abeyance Motion

• FTD’s Status Report
  Oct. 16, 2020
• FTD’s Status Report
  July 17, 2020
• FTD’s Status Report
  Apr. 16, 2020
• Order Granting Joint Motion for Abeyance
  Jan. 16, 2020
• Corrected Joint Motion for Abeyance
  Dec. 13, 2019
• NGOs’ Response in Support of Abeyance
  Dec. 12, 2019
• State Defendants’ Motion to Hold Case in Abeyance or Dismiss
  Nov. 22, 2019

Filings on Parties and Intervention

• Order Granting NGOs’ Intervention
  Jan. 16, 2020
• NGOs’ Motion to Intervene
  Dec. 12, 2019

Complaint

• FTD’s First Amended Complaint
  Oct. 30, 2019
• FTD’s Complaint
  Oct. 29, 2019